Another Earth

Dir. Mike Cahill

back to favorites


One of my more controversial choices for a favorite—which I know because many reviewers didn’t like it one bit, and at least one prominent critic put it on his “Year’s Worst” list.  But they are all very, very wrong, I assure you.  This is a marvelous film, which I would defend vigorously.  I just haven’t had the time yet to put together a critique that would do it any justice, and I think I need to watch the movie again before that can happen.  In the meantime, the following might give you a sense of it, although none of these reviewers actually likes the movie as much I do:


Roger Ebert:


Joshua Rothkopf (Time Out NY):


Tim Evans (Sky Movies):


Robbie Collin & Jenny McCarney (The Telegraph):




© 2012 dondi demarco